{"id":611484,"date":"2023-02-24T08:49:16","date_gmt":"2023-02-24T14:49:16","guid":{"rendered":"https:\/\/news.sellorbuyhomefast.com\/index.php\/2023\/02\/24\/social-media-used-to-be-free-not-anymore\/"},"modified":"2023-02-24T08:49:16","modified_gmt":"2023-02-24T14:49:16","slug":"social-media-used-to-be-free-not-anymore","status":"publish","type":"post","link":"https:\/\/newsycanuse.com\/index.php\/2023\/02\/24\/social-media-used-to-be-free-not-anymore\/","title":{"rendered":"Social media used to be free. Not anymore."},"content":{"rendered":"
\n

\u201cIf you\u2019re not paying for the product, you are the product\u201d has long been a common refrain about the business of social media.<\/p>\n

The saying implies that you, the user, aren\u2019t paying for apps like Instagram and Twitter because you\u2019re giving away something else: your attention (and sometimes your content), which is sold to advertisers. <\/p>\n

But now, this free model of social media \u2014 subsidized by advertising \u2014 is under pressure. Social media companies can\u2019t make as much money off their free users as they used to. A weaker advertising market<\/a>, privacy restrictions imposed by Apple<\/a> that make it harder to track users and their preferences, and the perpetual threat of regulation<\/a> have made it harder for social media apps to sell ads.<\/p>\n

Which is why we\u2019re seeing the beginnings of what might be a new era of social media: pay-to-play.<\/p>\n

On Sunday, Meta became the latest and largest major social media company to announce a paid version<\/a> of its products with the \u201cMeta Verified\u201d program. Facebook and Instagram will each charge users $12 a month for a blue verification badge, more protection against account impersonation, access to \u201ca real person\u201d in customer support to help with common account issues, and \u2014 most importantly \u2014 \u201dincreased reach and visibility.\u201d That means users who pay will have their content shown more in search, comments, and recommendations. The company is testing the feature in Australia and New Zealand this week and said it will be rolled out in the US and other countries soon.<\/p>\n

Meta\u2019s news comes a few months after Twitter released an $8-a-month paid verification program as part of new owner Elon Musk\u2019s revamped Twitter Blue product<\/a>. While Meta is notorious for cloning its competitors, its subscription offering isn\u2019t just another case of copycatting. It\u2019s part of an industry-wide trend. In recent years, Snap, YouTube, and Discord have introduced or expanded premium products that charge users for special perks. Snap<\/a> gives subscribers early access to new features, YouTube serves them<\/a> fewer ads, and Discord<\/a> provides more customization options for people\u2019s chat channels.<\/p>\n

Now, Meta \u2014 which owns the largest social media apps in the world \u2014 is validating the trend of a two-tiered user system in social media. In this system, only paid users will receive services that you might otherwise expect for free, like proactive protection from fraudsters who try to impersonate you, and a direct line of contact to customer support<\/a> when you\u2019re having technical difficulties. Meta says it\u2019s still offering some level of basic support to free users, but beyond that, it needs to charge to cover the cost.<\/p>\n

But the most newsworthy part of Meta\u2019s paid verification plan is not about how users who pay will get verified, or receive better customer support \u2014 but about how they\u2019ll also get more visibility<\/em> on Facebook and Instagram.<\/p>\n

In the past, in theory, everyone had the same opportunity to be seen on social media. Now, if you pay $12 a month on Meta Verified, you have better odds of other people finding your account and posts \u2014 because Meta\u2019s apps will uprank your content over that of other non-paying users. It\u2019s a system that creators who run professional businesses on Instagram and Facebook might find attractive but could also jeopardize the quality of users\u2019 experience if it\u2019s not executed carefully. <\/p>\n

With this new program, Meta is effectively blurring the line between advertising and organic content more than ever before. And with many users already complaining that Instagram can feel like a virtual shopping mall<\/a>, full of creators plugging their own content and products, it\u2019s hard to imagine that people will enjoy an even more commercialized experience. <\/p>\n

We don\u2019t yet know the full effects of what Meta Verified will be on the Facebook ecosystem. But it\u2019s clear that, moving forward, if you want to be fully seen, trusted, and taken care of on Facebook, Instagram, Twitter, and other platforms engaging in a premium model, you\u2019ll need to pay up.<\/p>\n

Security and support is now a luxury, not a given<\/h3>\n

If someone steals your credit card and impersonates you, you expect the bank to protect you. If you go to the supermarket and buy spoiled milk, you expect the cashier will give you a refund. Consumers expect a basic level of customer service from businesses. <\/p>\n

So it\u2019s understandable why some users<\/a> are reacting to Meta\u2019s news by arguing that basic services like customer support and account security should be free.<\/p>\n

\u201cThis really should just be part of the core product, the user should not have to pay for this,\u201d commented one user on Mark Zuckerberg\u2019s Facebook page after the announcement, to which Zuckerberg responded saying that Facebook will still provide some basic support to everyone \u2014 but that checking people\u2019s government IDs to verify them and providing on-call customer service is expensive, and Meta needs to charge to cover the cost.<\/p>\n

Social media\u2019s customer support and security offerings have always been somewhat broken and unreliable. Apps like Facebook \u2014 which serves 2 billion people a day, for free \u2014 have never effectively scaled basic programs like customer helplines to assist people who are locked out of their accounts, and verification has always been selective. Often, the users who receive personal attention are VIPs like government officials, celebrities, media figures, or people who happened to know someone who worked at the company.<\/p>\n

So while it may seem like Facebook is charging for something it used to do for free, it\u2019s actually charging for something it never did well.<\/p>\n

If you\u2019re an average user, you may not want to pay $24 a month for a blue badge on Facebook and Instagram, but if you run a business on these apps, it\u2019s a different story.<\/p>\n

Mae Karwowski, CEO of the social media influencer marketing firm Obviously, said that she could easily see \u201cso many people who run business empires\u201d on social media paying for the Meta Verified package as the \u201cnext logical step,\u201d because it could bring them even more business. The influencer industry on social media was worth an estimated $16 billion <\/a>in 2022, and although TikTok is growing, Instagram is still the most popular influencer marketing platform<\/a> for brands. Facebook and Instagram are also especially popular with business owners, with over 200 million businesses<\/a> active on Facebook alone, many of whom run their businesses on the network. <\/p>\n

The blue badge is important to creators and business owners, Karwowski said, because \u201cit\u2019s important to some people to have that credibility, or perceived credibility.\u201d <\/p>\n

Before Meta announced this paid tier, Karwowski said clients would often ask her for help getting verified on Instagram. You can apply to be verified on Instagram if you make the case that you\u2019re a notable public figure. But since so many people apply, it can take a long time to get your application through. <\/p>\n

\u201cPreviously, it would have to be like, \u2018Oh, like so-and-so\u2019s best friend\u2019s cousin works at Instagram.\u2019 And you find them on LinkedIn and send them a message,\u201d said Karwowski. \u201cThere was very little standardization. At least now there\u2019s some process.\u201d<\/p>\n

Still, some influencers Recode spoke with said they didn\u2019t see enough value in Meta Verified.<\/p>\n

\u201cI don\u2019t have a lot of people that are impersonating me. So that wouldn\u2019t really make it very important to me,\u201d said Oorbee Roy, a skateboarder and mom who goes by the handle @auntyskates. \u201cAnd the other thing is, I feel like I\u2019m close to getting [verified] on my own.\u201d<\/p>\n

What Roy did see as valuable was Instagram\u2019s promise of increased visibility. <\/p>\n

\u201cI have content that\u2019s very specific to a niche, and I would love to be able to get to that niche,\u201d she said.<\/p>\n

That gets us to our next point, about arguably the most valuable part of Facebook and Instagram\u2019s pay-to-play perks: more attention.<\/p>\n

Paying for reach<\/h3>\n

Before this announcement, if you wanted to boost a post or your account on Facebook or Instagram, you would have to run it as an ad \u2014 one that\u2019s clearly labeled as such to users, as either an ad, sponsored, or \u201cpaid content.\u201d (Instagram has long had a problem with creators posting unlabeled sponcon<\/a>, but that wasn\u2019t by design; users were essentially breaking the platform\u2019s rules.)<\/p>\n

Now, Instagram and Facebook are actually building in the ability for people to pay for eyeballs, without marking that promotion as advertising.<\/p>\n

\u201cThe notion that you\u2019re going to pay some subscription fee and then you\u2019ll feature more prominently in the algorithm \u2014 there\u2019s a name for that: It\u2019s advertising,\u201d said Jason Goldman, a former VP of product at Twitter from 2007 to 2010. \u201cIt\u2019s just a different way of pricing it.\u201d<\/p>\n

While these subscriptions may help make more money for Instagram and Facebook at a time when its traditional advertising business is struggling, it could also jeopardize its standing with users who don\u2019t want to see more promoted content.<\/p>\n

\u201cIt\u2019s kind of disappointing to see Instagram start to trend toward that commercial, more money-seeking business,\u201d said Erin Sheehan, a New York City-based lifestyle influencer with over 12,000 followers who goes by the handle @girlmeetsnewyorkcity.<\/p>\n

\u201cI kind of wanted to switch over to TikTok and get into that organic market, and I feel like this might even push me that step further,\u201d said Sheehan. \u201cBecause if I don\u2019t subscribe, then I may find that my content is even more hidden than it is now.\u201d<\/p>\n

TikTok has attracted a new generation of creators, many of whom switched to the platform<\/a> from older apps like Instagram because they say it\u2019s easier to go viral even if you\u2019re a relative amateur creating what Sheehan referenced as \u201corganic content.\u201d The app currently doesn\u2019t have a premium subscription model, but it\u2019s successfully expanding its advertising business<\/a> at a time when that of competitors like Meta and Snap have slowed down.<\/p>\n

Meta and other social media incumbents like YouTube have been battling TikTok for younger users and creators, with Instagram in particular rolling out new programs to court creators for Reels, its TikTok clone. So it\u2019s imperative that Instagram and Facebook make sure that users aren\u2019t turned off by promoted content from paid subscribers, and that creators keep wanting to share their content on their apps.<\/p>\n

Meta told Recode that it\u2019s still focused on surfacing content that people want to see.<\/p>\n

\u201cOur intent is to surface content that we think people will enjoy, and that doesn\u2019t change with the increased visibility we offer through Meta Verified,\u201d said Meta spokesperson Paige Cohen, in part, in a statement. \u201cAs we test and learn with Meta Verified, we\u2019ll be focused on ensuring we\u2019re enhancing the visibility of subscribers\u2019 content in a way that is most valuable to the ecosystem at large.\u201d<\/p>\n

Meta also said that it\u2019s not prioritizing paid content everywhere, for example: Subscribers will get prioritization in Explore and Reels on Instagram but not on the main feed. Reels, however, is a major focus for the company<\/a> as it competes with TikTok in the short-form video space, so prioritization there is in some ways more important than feed.<\/p>\n

It\u2019s still the early days of this developing pay-to-play social media model. But from what we know so far, only a small subset of users may be willing to pay. It\u2019s not a perfect comparison because it\u2019s a different platform with a distinct audience, but Twitter reportedly only has 0.2 percent of its total user base<\/a> paying for Twitter Blue as of mid-January. (The service launched in November.)<\/p>\n

Meta may have a better chance of finding more customers for its verified program because of its sheer scale (Meta has over 10 times the number of users as Twitter), the fact that it has more influencers who run real businesses on the platform, and that it\u2019s rolling this out in a more measured way than Twitter did.<\/p>\n

But there are major risks to this pay-to-play model. Whether it\u2019s normies posting pictures of their dogs and babies or professional influencers building their followings and careers, social media networks are built on their users. Creating tiers of those users could turn off some people from sharing at all. At a time when many young people are turning away from social media<\/a>, by either logging off completely or seeking alternative apps that feel more authentic and less commercial, Meta could be pushing away the users it needs the most to stay relevant in the future.<\/p>\n

rn rn vox-mark<\/title>rn rn <defs><\/defs>rn <g id=\"Page-1\" stroke=\"none\" stroke-width=\"1\" fill=\"none\" fill-rule=\"evenodd\" >rn <path d=\"M239.811,0 L238.424,6 L259.374,6 C278.011,6 292.908,17.38 292.908,43.002 C292.908,56.967 287.784,75.469 276.598,96.888 L182.689,305.687 L159.283,35.693 C159.283,13.809 168.134,6 191.88,6 L205.854,6 L207.247,0 L1.409,0 L0,6 L13.049,6 C28.88,6 35.863,15.885 37.264,34.514 L73.611,385 L160.221,385 L304.525,79.217 C328.749,31.719 349.237,6 372.525,6 L384.162,6 L385.557,0 L239.811,0\" id=\"vox-mark\" fill=\"#444745\" ><\/path>rn <\/g>rn<\/svg>“,”cross_community”:false,”groups”:[{“base_type”:”EntryGroup”,”id”:80301,”timestamp”:1677182851,”title”:”Recode”,”type”:”SiteGroup”,”url”:”https:\/\/www.vox.com\/recode”,”slug”:”recode”,”community_logo”:”rn<svg width=\"386px\" height=\"385px\" viewBox=\"0 0 386 385\" version=\"1.1\" xmlns=\"http:\/\/www.w3.org\/2000\/svg\" xmlns:xlink=\"http:\/\/www.w3.org\/1999\/xlink\" >rn rn <title>vox-mark<\/title>rn rn <defs><\/defs>rn <g id=\"Page-1\" stroke=\"none\" stroke-width=\"1\" fill=\"none\" fill-rule=\"evenodd\" >rn <path d=\"M239.811,0 L238.424,6 L259.374,6 C278.011,6 292.908,17.38 292.908,43.002 C292.908,56.967 287.784,75.469 276.598,96.888 L182.689,305.687 L159.283,35.693 C159.283,13.809 168.134,6 191.88,6 L205.854,6 L207.247,0 L1.409,0 L0,6 L13.049,6 C28.88,6 35.863,15.885 37.264,34.514 L73.611,385 L160.221,385 L304.525,79.217 C328.749,31.719 349.237,6 372.525,6 L384.162,6 L385.557,0 L239.811,0\" id=\"vox-mark\" fill=\"#444745\" ><\/path>rn <\/g>rn<\/svg>“,”community_name”:”Vox”,”community_url”:”https:\/\/www.vox.com\/”,”cross_community”:false,”entry_count”:22897,”always_show”:false,”description”:”Uncovering and explaining how our digital world is changing \u2014 and changing us.”,”disclosure”:””,”cover_image_url”:””,”cover_image”:null,”title_image_url”:”https:\/\/cdn.vox-cdn.com\/uploads\/chorus_asset\/file\/16201674\/REC_Wordmark_Red_RGB.0.png”,”intro_image”:null,”four_up_see_more_text”:”View All”,”primary”:true},{“base_type”:”EntryGroup”,”id”:27524,”timestamp”:1677182849,”title”:”Technology”,”type”:”SiteGroup”,”url”:”https:\/\/www.vox.com\/technology”,”slug”:”technology”,”community_logo”:”rn<svg width=\"386px\" height=\"385px\" viewBox=\"0 0 386 385\" version=\"1.1\" xmlns=\"http:\/\/www.w3.org\/2000\/svg\" xmlns:xlink=\"http:\/\/www.w3.org\/1999\/xlink\" >rn rn <title>vox-mark<\/title>rn rn <defs><\/defs>rn <g id=\"Page-1\" stroke=\"none\" stroke-width=\"1\" fill=\"none\" fill-rule=\"evenodd\" >rn <path d=\"M239.811,0 L238.424,6 L259.374,6 C278.011,6 292.908,17.38 292.908,43.002 C292.908,56.967 287.784,75.469 276.598,96.888 L182.689,305.687 L159.283,35.693 C159.283,13.809 168.134,6 191.88,6 L205.854,6 L207.247,0 L1.409,0 L0,6 L13.049,6 C28.88,6 35.863,15.885 37.264,34.514 L73.611,385 L160.221,385 L304.525,79.217 C328.749,31.719 349.237,6 372.525,6 L384.162,6 L385.557,0 L239.811,0\" id=\"vox-mark\" fill=\"#444745\" ><\/path>rn <\/g>rn<\/svg>“,”community_name”:”Vox”,”community_url”:”https:\/\/www.vox.com\/”,”cross_community”:false,”entry_count”:2246,”always_show”:false,”description”:”How new technology is transforming cities and societies, from the latest apps to advances in renewable energy, computing, transportation, and more.”,”disclosure”:””,”cover_image_url”:””,”cover_image”:null,”title_image_url”:”https:\/\/cdn.vox-cdn.com\/uploads\/chorus_asset\/file\/22360844\/VoxTech_Highlight_2.gif”,”intro_image”:null,”four_up_see_more_text”:”View All”,”primary”:false},{“base_type”:”EntryGroup”,”id”:27608,”timestamp”:1677180515,”title”:”Culture”,”type”:”SiteGroup”,”url”:”https:\/\/www.vox.com\/culture”,”slug”:”culture”,”community_logo”:”rn<svg width=\"386px\" height=\"385px\" viewBox=\"0 0 386 385\" version=\"1.1\" xmlns=\"http:\/\/www.w3.org\/2000\/svg\" xmlns:xlink=\"http:\/\/www.w3.org\/1999\/xlink\" >rn rn <title>vox-mark<\/title>rn rn <defs><\/defs>rn <g id=\"Page-1\" stroke=\"none\" stroke-width=\"1\" fill=\"none\" fill-rule=\"evenodd\" >rn <path d=\"M239.811,0 L238.424,6 L259.374,6 C278.011,6 292.908,17.38 292.908,43.002 C292.908,56.967 287.784,75.469 276.598,96.888 L182.689,305.687 L159.283,35.693 C159.283,13.809 168.134,6 191.88,6 L205.854,6 L207.247,0 L1.409,0 L0,6 L13.049,6 C28.88,6 35.863,15.885 37.264,34.514 L73.611,385 L160.221,385 L304.525,79.217 C328.749,31.719 349.237,6 372.525,6 L384.162,6 L385.557,0 L239.811,0\" id=\"vox-mark\" fill=\"#444745\" ><\/path>rn <\/g>rn<\/svg>“,”community_name”:”Vox”,”community_url”:”https:\/\/www.vox.com\/”,”cross_community”:false,”entry_count”:11069,”always_show”:false,”description”:”Stay up to date on the latest in television and movie reviews, books, celebrity culture, and more.rn”,”disclosure”:””,”cover_image_url”:””,”cover_image”:null,”title_image_url”:””,”intro_image”:null,”four_up_see_more_text”:”View All”,”primary”:false},{“base_type”:”EntryGroup”,”id”:61263,”timestamp”:1677020103,”title”:”Internet Culture”,”type”:”SiteGroup”,”url”:”https:\/\/www.vox.com\/internet-culture”,”slug”:”internet-culture”,”community_logo”:”rn<svg width=\"386px\" height=\"385px\" viewBox=\"0 0 386 385\" version=\"1.1\" xmlns=\"http:\/\/www.w3.org\/2000\/svg\" xmlns:xlink=\"http:\/\/www.w3.org\/1999\/xlink\" >rn rn <title>vox-mark<\/title>rn rn <defs><\/defs>rn <g id=\"Page-1\" stroke=\"none\" stroke-width=\"1\" fill=\"none\" fill-rule=\"evenodd\" >rn <path d=\"M239.811,0 L238.424,6 L259.374,6 C278.011,6 292.908,17.38 292.908,43.002 C292.908,56.967 287.784,75.469 276.598,96.888 L182.689,305.687 L159.283,35.693 C159.283,13.809 168.134,6 191.88,6 L205.854,6 L207.247,0 L1.409,0 L0,6 L13.049,6 C28.88,6 35.863,15.885 37.264,34.514 L73.611,385 L160.221,385 L304.525,79.217 C328.749,31.719 349.237,6 372.525,6 L384.162,6 L385.557,0 L239.811,0\" id=\"vox-mark\" fill=\"#444745\" ><\/path>rn <\/g>rn<\/svg>“,”community_name”:”Vox”,”community_url”:”https:\/\/www.vox.com\/”,”cross_community”:false,”entry_count”:636,”always_show”:false,”description”:”Vox’s coverage of the latest memes, social media controversies, YouTube drama, and more.”,”disclosure”:””,”cover_image_url”:””,”cover_image”:null,”title_image_url”:””,”intro_image”:null,”four_up_see_more_text”:”View All”,”primary”:false},{“base_type”:”EntryGroup”,”id”:71037,”timestamp”:1677098625,”title”:”Social Media”,”type”:”SiteGroup”,”url”:”https:\/\/www.vox.com\/social-media”,”slug”:”social-media”,”community_logo”:”rn<svg width=\"386px\" height=\"385px\" viewBox=\"0 0 386 385\" version=\"1.1\" xmlns=\"http:\/\/www.w3.org\/2000\/svg\" xmlns:xlink=\"http:\/\/www.w3.org\/1999\/xlink\" >rn rn <title>vox-mark<\/title>rn rn <defs><\/defs>rn <g id=\"Page-1\" stroke=\"none\" stroke-width=\"1\" fill=\"none\" fill-rule=\"evenodd\" >rn <path d=\"M239.811,0 L238.424,6 L259.374,6 C278.011,6 292.908,17.38 292.908,43.002 C292.908,56.967 287.784,75.469 276.598,96.888 L182.689,305.687 L159.283,35.693 C159.283,13.809 168.134,6 191.88,6 L205.854,6 L207.247,0 L1.409,0 L0,6 L13.049,6 C28.88,6 35.863,15.885 37.264,34.514 L73.611,385 L160.221,385 L304.525,79.217 C328.749,31.719 349.237,6 372.525,6 L384.162,6 L385.557,0 L239.811,0\" id=\"vox-mark\" fill=\"#444745\" ><\/path>rn <\/g>rn<\/svg>“,”community_name”:”Vox”,”community_url”:”https:\/\/www.vox.com\/”,”cross_community”:false,”entry_count”:633,”always_show”:false,”description”:”From Facebook to Twitter to YouTube, social media platforms are transforming communication and <a href=\"https:\/\/www.vox.com\/internet-culture\">internet culture<\/a>, even as they raise privacy concerns for users.”,”disclosure”:””,”cover_image_url”:””,”cover_image”:null,”title_image_url”:””,”intro_image”:null,”four_up_see_more_text”:”View All”,”primary”:false},{“base_type”:”EntryGroup”,”id”:80387,”timestamp”:1677020103,”title”:”Mark Zuckerberg”,”type”:”SiteGroup”,”url”:”https:\/\/www.vox.com\/mark-zuckerberg”,”slug”:”mark-zuckerberg”,”community_logo”:”rn<svg width=\"386px\" height=\"385px\" viewBox=\"0 0 386 385\" version=\"1.1\" xmlns=\"http:\/\/www.w3.org\/2000\/svg\" xmlns:xlink=\"http:\/\/www.w3.org\/1999\/xlink\" >rn rn <title>vox-mark<\/title>rn rn <defs><\/defs>rn <g id=\"Page-1\" stroke=\"none\" stroke-width=\"1\" fill=\"none\" fill-rule=\"evenodd\" >rn <path d=\"M239.811,0 L238.424,6 L259.374,6 C278.011,6 292.908,17.38 292.908,43.002 C292.908,56.967 287.784,75.469 276.598,96.888 L182.689,305.687 L159.283,35.693 C159.283,13.809 168.134,6 191.88,6 L205.854,6 L207.247,0 L1.409,0 L0,6 L13.049,6 C28.88,6 35.863,15.885 37.264,34.514 L73.611,385 L160.221,385 L304.525,79.217 C328.749,31.719 349.237,6 372.525,6 L384.162,6 L385.557,0 L239.811,0\" id=\"vox-mark\" fill=\"#444745\" ><\/path>rn <\/g>rn<\/svg>“,”community_name”:”Vox”,”community_url”:”https:\/\/www.vox.com\/”,”cross_community”:false,”entry_count”:270,”always_show”:false,”description”:””,”disclosure”:””,”cover_image_url”:””,”cover_image”:null,”title_image_url”:””,”intro_image”:null,”four_up_see_more_text”:”View All”,”primary”:false},{“base_type”:”EntryGroup”,”id”:80419,”timestamp”:1677098625,”title”:”Twitter”,”type”:”SiteGroup”,”url”:”https:\/\/www.vox.com\/twitter”,”slug”:”twitter”,”community_logo”:”rn<svg width=\"386px\" height=\"385px\" viewBox=\"0 0 386 385\" version=\"1.1\" xmlns=\"http:\/\/www.w3.org\/2000\/svg\" xmlns:xlink=\"http:\/\/www.w3.org\/1999\/xlink\" >rn rn <title>vox-mark<\/title>rn rn <defs><\/defs>rn <g id=\"Page-1\" stroke=\"none\" stroke-width=\"1\" fill=\"none\" fill-rule=\"evenodd\" >rn <path d=\"M239.811,0 L238.424,6 L259.374,6 C278.011,6 292.908,17.38 292.908,43.002 C292.908,56.967 287.784,75.469 276.598,96.888 L182.689,305.687 L159.283,35.693 C159.283,13.809 168.134,6 191.88,6 L205.854,6 L207.247,0 L1.409,0 L0,6 L13.049,6 C28.88,6 35.863,15.885 37.264,34.514 L73.611,385 L160.221,385 L304.525,79.217 C328.749,31.719 349.237,6 372.525,6 L384.162,6 L385.557,0 L239.811,0\" id=\"vox-mark\" fill=\"#444745\" ><\/path>rn <\/g>rn<\/svg>“,”community_name”:”Vox”,”community_url”:”https:\/\/www.vox.com\/”,”cross_community”:false,”entry_count”:1543,”always_show”:false,”description”:””,”disclosure”:””,”cover_image_url”:””,”cover_image”:null,”title_image_url”:””,”intro_image”:null,”four_up_see_more_text”:”View All”,”primary”:false},{“base_type”:”EntryGroup”,”id”:102796,”timestamp”:1677020103,”title”:”Influence”,”type”:”SiteGroup”,”url”:”https:\/\/www.vox.com\/influence”,”slug”:”influence”,”community_logo”:”rn<svg width=\"386px\" height=\"385px\" viewBox=\"0 0 386 385\" version=\"1.1\" xmlns=\"http:\/\/www.w3.org\/2000\/svg\" xmlns:xlink=\"http:\/\/www.w3.org\/1999\/xlink\" >rn rn <title>vox-mark<\/title>rn rn <defs><\/defs>rn <g id=\"Page-1\" stroke=\"none\" stroke-width=\"1\" fill=\"none\" fill-rule=\"evenodd\" >rn <path d=\"M239.811,0 L238.424,6 L259.374,6 C278.011,6 292.908,17.38 292.908,43.002 C292.908,56.967 287.784,75.469 276.598,96.888 L182.689,305.687 L159.283,35.693 C159.283,13.809 168.134,6 191.88,6 L205.854,6 L207.247,0 L1.409,0 L0,6 L13.049,6 C28.88,6 35.863,15.885 37.264,34.514 L73.611,385 L160.221,385 L304.525,79.217 C328.749,31.719 349.237,6 372.525,6 L384.162,6 L385.557,0 L239.811,0\" id=\"vox-mark\" fill=\"#444745\" ><\/path>rn <\/g>rn<\/svg>“,”community_name”:”Vox”,”community_url”:”https:\/\/www.vox.com\/”,”cross_community”:false,”entry_count”:190,”always_show”:false,”description”:””,”disclosure”:””,”cover_image_url”:””,”cover_image”:null,”title_image_url”:””,”intro_image”:null,”four_up_see_more_text”:”View All”,”primary”:false},{“base_type”:”EntryGroup”,”id”:112373,”timestamp”:1677182849,”title”:”Meta”,”type”:”SiteGroup”,”url”:”https:\/\/www.vox.com\/meta”,”slug”:”meta”,”community_logo”:”rn<svg width=\"386px\" height=\"385px\" viewBox=\"0 0 386 385\" version=\"1.1\" xmlns=\"http:\/\/www.w3.org\/2000\/svg\" xmlns:xlink=\"http:\/\/www.w3.org\/1999\/xlink\" >rn rn <title>vox-mark<\/title>rn rn <defs><\/defs>rn <g id=\"Page-1\" stroke=\"none\" stroke-width=\"1\" fill=\"none\" fill-rule=\"evenodd\" >rn <path d=\"M239.811,0 L238.424,6 L259.374,6 C278.011,6 292.908,17.38 292.908,43.002 C292.908,56.967 287.784,75.469 276.598,96.888 L182.689,305.687 L159.283,35.693 C159.283,13.809 168.134,6 191.88,6 L205.854,6 L207.247,0 L1.409,0 L0,6 L13.049,6 C28.88,6 35.863,15.885 37.264,34.514 L73.611,385 L160.221,385 L304.525,79.217 C328.749,31.719 349.237,6 372.525,6 L384.162,6 L385.557,0 L239.811,0\" id=\"vox-mark\" fill=\"#444745\" ><\/path>rn <\/g>rn<\/svg>“,”community_name”:”Vox”,”community_url”:”https:\/\/www.vox.com\/”,”cross_community”:false,”entry_count”:94,”always_show”:false,”description”:”Vox’s news and analysis on the state of Meta, the parent company of Facebook, Instagram, and WhatsApp, and its future as a player in Big Tech.”,”disclosure”:””,”cover_image_url”:””,”cover_image”:null,”title_image_url”:””,”intro_image”:null,”four_up_see_more_text”:”View All”,”primary”:false}],”internal_groups”:[],”image”:{“ratio”:”*”,”original_url”:”https:\/\/cdn.vox-cdn.com\/uploads\/chorus_image\/image\/71999768\/1246290773.0.jpg”,”network”:”unison”,”bgcolor”:”white”,”pinterest_enabled”:false,”caption”:”Sandra Hunke, a plumber who is one of the most popular craft influencers in Germany with 120,000 Instagram followers and now also works part-time as a model, poses for a photo in her workshop in North Rhine-Westphalia.”,”credit”:”Friso Gentsch\/picture alliance via Getty Images”,”focal_area”:{“top_left_x”:2259,”top_left_y”:689,”bottom_right_x”:3121,”bottom_right_y”:1551},”bounds”:[0,0,5396,3597],”uploaded_size”:{“width”:5396,”height”:3597},”focal_point”:null,”image_id”:71999768,”alt_text”:”Sandra Hunke in a workspace seen in a camera phone lens. “},”hub_image”:{“ratio”:”*”,”original_url”:”https:\/\/cdn.vox-cdn.com\/uploads\/chorus_image\/image\/71999768\/1246290773.0.jpg”,”network”:”unison”,”bgcolor”:”white”,”pinterest_enabled”:false,”caption”:”Sandra Hunke, a plumber who is one of the most popular craft influencers in Germany with 120,000 Instagram followers and now also works part-time as a model, poses for a photo in her workshop in North Rhine-Westphalia.”,”credit”:”Friso Gentsch\/picture alliance via Getty Images”,”focal_area”:{“top_left_x”:2259,”top_left_y”:689,”bottom_right_x”:3121,”bottom_right_y”:1551},”bounds”:[0,0,5396,3597],”uploaded_size”:{“width”:5396,”height”:3597},”focal_point”:null,”image_id”:71999768,”alt_text”:”Sandra Hunke in a workspace seen in a camera phone lens. “},”lede_image”:{“ratio”:”*”,”original_url”:”https:\/\/cdn.vox-cdn.com\/uploads\/chorus_image\/image\/71999769\/1246290773.0.jpg”,”network”:”unison”,”bgcolor”:”white”,”pinterest_enabled”:false,”caption”:”Sandra Hunke, a plumber who is one of the most popular craft influencers in Germany with 120,000 Instagram followers and now also works part-time as a model, poses for a photo in her workshop in North Rhine-Westphalia.”,”credit”:”Friso Gentsch\/picture alliance via Getty Images”,”focal_area”:{“top_left_x”:2259,”top_left_y”:689,”bottom_right_x”:3121,”bottom_right_y”:1551},”bounds”:[0,0,5396,3597],”uploaded_size”:{“width”:5396,”height”:3597},”focal_point”:null,”image_id”:71999769,”alt_text”:”Sandra Hunke in a workspace seen in a camera phone lens. “},”group_cover_image”:null,”picture_standard_lead_image”:{“ratio”:”*”,”original_url”:”https:\/\/cdn.vox-cdn.com\/uploads\/chorus_image\/image\/71999769\/1246290773.0.jpg”,”network”:”unison”,”bgcolor”:”white”,”pinterest_enabled”:false,”caption”:”Sandra Hunke, a plumber who is one of the most popular craft influencers in Germany with 120,000 Instagram followers and now also works part-time as a model, poses for a photo in her workshop in North Rhine-Westphalia.”,”credit”:”Friso Gentsch\/picture alliance via Getty Images”,”focal_area”:{“top_left_x”:2259,”top_left_y”:689,”bottom_right_x”:3121,”bottom_right_y”:1551},”bounds”:[0,0,5396,3597],”uploaded_size”:{“width”:5396,”height”:3597},”focal_point”:null,”image_id”:71999769,”alt_text”:”Sandra Hunke in a workspace seen in a camera phone lens. “,”picture_element”:{“html”:{},”alt”:”Sandra Hunke in a workspace seen in a camera phone lens. “,”default”:{“srcset”:”https:\/\/cdn.vox-cdn.com\/thumbor\/9wKGYCG0f8fpbwimCjZy5eDfb7c=\/0x0:5396×3597\/320×240\/filters:focal(2259×689:3121×1551)\/cdn.vox-cdn.com\/uploads\/chorus_image\/image\/71999769\/1246290773.0.jpg 320w, https:\/\/cdn.vox-cdn.com\/thumbor\/23pZkt68WiisQMzBMerJYQHnVBw=\/0x0:5396×3597\/620×465\/filters:focal(2259×689:3121×1551)\/cdn.vox-cdn.com\/uploads\/chorus_image\/image\/71999769\/1246290773.0.jpg 620w, https:\/\/cdn.vox-cdn.com\/thumbor\/uhdEZGxb5sA8qSeqYGP33lgOi9Q=\/0x0:5396×3597\/920×690\/filters:focal(2259×689:3121×1551)\/cdn.vox-cdn.com\/uploads\/chorus_image\/image\/71999769\/1246290773.0.jpg 920w, https:\/\/cdn.vox-cdn.com\/thumbor\/2mymZptTyBo5ocShZAXaPdYOwpc=\/0x0:5396×3597\/1220×915\/filters:focal(2259×689:3121×1551)\/cdn.vox-cdn.com\/uploads\/chorus_image\/image\/71999769\/1246290773.0.jpg 1220w, https:\/\/cdn.vox-cdn.com\/thumbor\/McYvtctafe8zLAOwjdBxvFAIYrg=\/0x0:5396×3597\/1520×1140\/filters:focal(2259×689:3121×1551)\/cdn.vox-cdn.com\/uploads\/chorus_image\/image\/71999769\/1246290773.0.jpg 1520w”,”webp_srcset”:”https:\/\/cdn.vox-cdn.com\/thumbor\/cUVQ1a__Fx7hNQFss3AxVKU7uvU=\/0x0:5396×3597\/320×240\/filters:focal(2259×689:3121×1551):format(webp)\/cdn.vox-cdn.com\/uploads\/chorus_image\/image\/71999769\/1246290773.0.jpg 320w, https:\/\/cdn.vox-cdn.com\/thumbor\/jfzCz2BmuLPtSvgkHdwk3Y1zRf4=\/0x0:5396×3597\/620×465\/filters:focal(2259×689:3121×1551):format(webp)\/cdn.vox-cdn.com\/uploads\/chorus_image\/image\/71999769\/1246290773.0.jpg 620w, https:\/\/cdn.vox-cdn.com\/thumbor\/hdhye4h8LsFETk0doXudPu69ytk=\/0x0:5396×3597\/920×690\/filters:focal(2259×689:3121×1551):format(webp)\/cdn.vox-cdn.com\/uploads\/chorus_image\/image\/71999769\/1246290773.0.jpg 920w, https:\/\/cdn.vox-cdn.com\/thumbor\/EAW4rk0iAD3G2nBOPto4D_pS2Vg=\/0x0:5396×3597\/1220×915\/filters:focal(2259×689:3121×1551):format(webp)\/cdn.vox-cdn.com\/uploads\/chorus_image\/image\/71999769\/1246290773.0.jpg 1220w, https:\/\/cdn.vox-cdn.com\/thumbor\/XeVFHCxHaM3jyekUjl7lZznpf5c=\/0x0:5396×3597\/1520×1140\/filters:focal(2259×689:3121×1551):format(webp)\/cdn.vox-cdn.com\/uploads\/chorus_image\/image\/71999769\/1246290773.0.jpg 1520w”,”media”:null,”sizes”:”(min-width: 809px) 485px, (min-width: 600px) 60vw, 100vw”,”fallback”:”https:\/\/cdn.vox-cdn.com\/thumbor\/skBq7rNkGJOHOWS9ZqBhl5YhrOc=\/0x0:5396×3597\/1200×900\/filters:focal(2259×689:3121×1551)\/cdn.vox-cdn.com\/uploads\/chorus_image\/image\/71999769\/1246290773.0.jpg”},”art_directed”:[]}},”image_is_placeholder”:false,”image_is_hidden”:false,”network”:”vox”,”omits_labels”:true,”optimizable”:false,”promo_headline”:”Social media used to be free. Not anymore.”,”recommended_count”:0,”recs_enabled”:false,”slug”:”recode\/2023\/2\/21\/23609375\/meta-verified-twitter-blue-checkmark-badge-instagram-facebook”,”dek”:”You used to pay for social media with your eyeballs. Now Meta and Twitter want your money, too.”,”homepage_title”:”Social media used to be free. Not anymore.”,”homepage_description”:”You used to pay for social media with your eyeballs. Now Meta and Twitter want your money, too.”,”show_homepage_description”:false,”title_display”:”Social media used to be free. Not anymore.”,”pull_quote”:null,”voxcreative”:false,”show_entry_time”:true,”show_dates”:true,”paywalled_content”:false,”paywalled_content_box_logo_url”:””,”paywalled_content_page_logo_url”:””,”paywalled_content_main_url”:””,”article_footer_body”:”Millions turn to Vox to educate themselves, their family, and their friends about what\u2019s happening in the world around them, and to learn about things that spark their curiosity. Financial contributions from our readers are a critical part of supporting our resource-intensive work and help us keep our journalism free for all. rn <a href=\"rnhttp:\/\/vox.com\/pages\/support-now?itm_campaign=jan2023-footer&itm_medium=site&itm_source=article-footer_default \">Please consider making a one-time contribution to Vox today.rn<\/a>“,”article_footer_header”:”<a href=\"http:\/\/vox.com\/pages\/support-now?itm_campaign=help-us-plan-eoy22&itm_medium=site&itm_source=article-footer \">Will you support Vox\u2019s explanatory journalism?<\/a>“,”use_article_footer”:true,”article_footer_cta_annual_plans”:”{rn “default_plan”: 1,rn “plans”: [rn {rn “amount”: 95,rn “plan_id”: 74295rn },rn {rn “amount”: 120,rn “plan_id”: 81108rn },rn {rn “amount”: 250,rn “plan_id”: 77096rn }rn ]rn}”,”article_footer_cta_button_annual_copy”:”year”,”article_footer_cta_button_copy”:”Yes, I’ll give”,”article_footer_cta_button_monthly_copy”:”month”,”article_footer_cta_default_frequency”:”annual”,”article_footer_cta_monthly_plans”:”{rn “default_plan”: 1,rn “plans”: [rn {rn “amount”: 9,rn “plan_id”: 77780rn },rn {rn “amount”: 20,rn “plan_id”: 69279rn },rn {rn “amount”: 50,rn “plan_id”: 46947rn }rn ]rn}”,”article_footer_cta_once_plans”:”{rn “default_plan”: 0,rn “plans”: [rn {rn “amount”: 20,rn “plan_id”: 69278rn },rn {rn “amount”: 50,rn “plan_id”: 48880rn },rn {rn “amount”: 100,rn “plan_id”: 46607rn }rn ]rn}”,”use_article_footer_cta_read_counter”:true,”use_article_footer_cta”:true,”featured_placeable”:false,”video_placeable”:false,”disclaimer”:null,”volume_placement”:”lede”,”video_autoplay”:false,”youtube_url”:”http:\/\/bit.ly\/voxyoutube”,”facebook_video_url”:””,”play_in_modal”:true,”user_preferences_for_privacy_enabled”:false,”show_branded_logos”:true}”><\/p>\n<div>\n<p><label tabindex=\"0\" role=\"radio\" aria-checked=\"true\"><\/p>\n<p>\n <span>$95<\/span><span>\/year<\/span>\n <\/p>\n<p> <\/label><\/p>\n<p> <label tabindex=\"0\" role=\"radio\" aria-checked=\"true\"><\/p>\n<p>\n <span>$120<\/span><span>\/year<\/span>\n <\/p>\n<p> <\/label><\/p>\n<p> <label tabindex=\"0\" role=\"radio\" aria-checked=\"true\"><\/p>\n<p>\n <span>$250<\/span><span>\/year<\/span>\n <\/p>\n<p> <\/label><\/p>\n<p> <label tabindex=\"0\"><\/p>\n<p> <span>Other<\/span><br \/>\n <\/label>\n <\/p>\n<\/p><\/div>\n<p> <a href=\"https:\/\/vox.memberful.com\/checkout?plan=\" id=\"contribute--submit\"><\/p>\n<p>\n Yes, I’ll give $120<span>\/year<\/span>\n <\/p>\n<p> <\/a><\/p>\n<p>\n Yes, I’ll give $120<span>\/year<\/span>\n <\/p>\n<div>\n<p>\n <span><br \/>\n We accept credit card, Apple Pay, and<br \/>\n <\/span><br \/>\n <span><br \/>\n Google Pay. You can also contribute via<br \/>\n <\/span>\n <\/p>\n<p><a href=\"https:\/\/www.paypal.com\/donate\/?hosted_button_id=VSP4PYJX98SHL\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\"><br \/>\n <img decoding=\"async\" src=\"https:\/\/cdn.vox-cdn.com\/uploads\/chorus_asset\/file\/22734206\/paypal_logo.png\"><br \/>\n <\/a>\n <\/p>\n<\/div><\/div>\n<\/div>\n<p><a href=\"https:\/\/www.vox.com\/recode\/2023\/2\/21\/23609375\/meta-verified-twitter-blue-checkmark-badge-instagram-facebook\" class=\"button purchase\" rel=\"nofollow noopener\" target=\"_blank\">Read More<\/a><br \/>\n Qiana Schewe<\/p>\n","protected":false},"excerpt":{"rendered":"<p>\u201cIf you\u2019re not paying for the product, you are the product\u201d has long been a common refrain about the business of social media. The saying implies that you, the user, aren\u2019t paying for apps like Instagram and Twitter because you\u2019re giving away something else: your attention (and sometimes your content), which is sold to advertisers.<\/p>\n","protected":false},"author":1,"featured_media":611485,"comment_status":"closed","ping_status":"closed","sticky":false,"template":"","format":"standard","meta":{"footnotes":""},"categories":[1125,700,46],"tags":[],"class_list":["post-611484","post","type-post","status-publish","format-standard","has-post-thumbnail","category-media","category-social","category-technology"],"aioseo_notices":[],"_links":{"self":[{"href":"https:\/\/newsycanuse.com\/index.php\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/posts\/611484","targetHints":{"allow":["GET"]}}],"collection":[{"href":"https:\/\/newsycanuse.com\/index.php\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/posts"}],"about":[{"href":"https:\/\/newsycanuse.com\/index.php\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/types\/post"}],"author":[{"embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/newsycanuse.com\/index.php\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/users\/1"}],"replies":[{"embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/newsycanuse.com\/index.php\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/comments?post=611484"}],"version-history":[{"count":0,"href":"https:\/\/newsycanuse.com\/index.php\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/posts\/611484\/revisions"}],"wp:featuredmedia":[{"embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/newsycanuse.com\/index.php\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/media\/611485"}],"wp:attachment":[{"href":"https:\/\/newsycanuse.com\/index.php\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/media?parent=611484"}],"wp:term":[{"taxonomy":"category","embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/newsycanuse.com\/index.php\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/categories?post=611484"},{"taxonomy":"post_tag","embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/newsycanuse.com\/index.php\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/tags?post=611484"}],"curies":[{"name":"wp","href":"https:\/\/api.w.org\/{rel}","templated":true}]}}