Which Fall Bake You Should Make Based on Your Zodiac Sign

There’s no mincing words: Fall is the best time for baking. The scent of warming spices filling the kitchen on a chilly day is one of life’s greatest pleasures. Whether you love pumpkin or prefer apple, there’s so much to appreciate about seasonal baking.

But once the temperature drops, I’m usually faced with the difficult decision of what to bake next. This indecision could be attributed to the wealth of recipes at my fingertips, or to the fact that I’m a Libra. Difficulty making a decision is part of a Libra’s DNA—we’re always trying to balance our options for as long as we can.

So I’m here to make this decision easier for you than it is for me. I’ve compiled a list of fun fall recipes for each zodiac sign. The next time you’re stuck, look no further than your birthday when making a decision. And bonus points if you know your rising sign or moon sign—that means you have your next three bakes all lined up!

1
/
12

Recipes Aries (March 21 to April 20): Slow Cooker Pumpkin Pie Pudding

It’s no secret that you never stop moving, Aries. And I get it! There’s a lot on your plate, and it feels like there’s never enough time to tackle it all. Never fear, because I have the answer to your holiday dessert plans: your slow-cooker. It’s not just for dips or chili; it can also make delicious desserts. This pumpkin pie pudding recipe can cook in the background while you check off other things on your to-do list. Prepare for your guests to be amazed.

Get the recipe: Slow Cooker Pumpkin Pie Pudding

2
/
12

Recipes Taurus (April 21 to May 21): Pecan Cheesecake Pie

I have a soft spot for you, Taurus, because I know I will always be fed well at your house. A Taurus lives for luxury and decadence, and that is exactly how I would describe this pecan cheesecake pie. A mouthwatering combination of two of fall’s most beloved desserts: pecan pie and cheesecake. And as the zodiac’s lovably stubborn bull, I’m sure you will force guests to take home a slice as well.

Get the recipe: Pecan Cheesecake Pie

3
/
12

Recipes Gemini (May 22 to June 21): Cranberry-Carrot Layer Cake

Gemini loves giving their guests something to talk about. As a chatty air sign, you know how to keep conversations going—and wine flowing. The combination of flavors in this cranberry-carrot layer cake is a nice homage to the twins who represent your zodiac sign. It’s also guaranteed to delight your guests, and it makes a stunning centerpiece for any dinner table.

Get the recipe: Cranberry-Carrot Layer Cake

4
/
12

Recipes Cancer (June 22 to July 23): Squash Focaccia

There’s no place I’d rather be on a blustery fall day than in your house, Cancer. You are the epitome of comfort and hospitality, and will probably serve this savory squash focaccia alongside a heaping bowl of soup. The combination of roasted squash, sage and flaky sea salt will make everyone’s mouth water—in fact, you’d better bake two, just to be safe.

Get the recipe: Squash Focaccia

5
/
12

Recipes Leo (July 24 to August 23): Brown Butter Blondies with Speculoos Buttercream

Leo, I know exactly what you need: a rockstar recipe that will blow everyone’s minds. Whether you’re baking them to share at a potluck or simply serving them alongside cocktails at your own place, these blondies are the “it” girl of fall recipes. The brown butter adds a depth of flavor, and the cookie butter buttercream is easily one of the most delicious toppings ever created. Go ahead, knock them off their feet.

Get the recipe: Brown Butter Blondies with Speculoos Buttercream

6
/
12

Recipes Virgo (August 24 to September 23): Apple Cider Doughnut Cake

Virgo is enchanted by simplicity. You don’t need flashy toppings or trendy recipes to wow a crowd, and I know that you’re secretly harboring a preference for apple flavors over pumpkin ones this fall. This recipe turns apple cider doughnuts into a cake, so it’s much easier to whip up and keep on hand. Even if everything else doesn’t go according to your plans, I guarantee that this cake will not disappoint.

Get the recipe: Apple Cider Doughnut Cake

7
/
12

Recipes Libra (September 24 to October 23): Pumpkin-Shaped Rolls

Libra’s hosting motto is basically, “If it’s not beautiful, I don’t want it on my table.” That’s where these showstopping pumpkin rolls come into play. Anyone can serve a batch of dinner rolls, but only you can make them the star of the night. Pumpkin and cheddar cheese combine to make these as delicious as they are cute. It’s all very chic, no?

Get the recipe: Pumpkin-Shaped Rolls

8
/
12

Recipes Scorpio (October 24 to November 22): Chocolate Maple Bars

I saved one of the only chocolate recipes for you, dear Scorpio. No one else would really do it justice! The depth of fall is reserved for you, and I think you will appreciate an elevated candy bar—even after Halloween is over. These bars combine chocolate, maple, coconut, pecans and mini marshmallows into an incredibly decadent and satisfying treat.

Get the recipe: Chocolate Maple Bars

9
/
12

Recipes Sagittarius (November 23 to December 21): Chai Cinnamon Rolls

Fiery Sagittarius loves to throw a party, and wants to make sure everyone can really unwind and enjoy themselves. Enter these unexpected chai cinnamon rolls. They may look like basic cinnamon rolls, but the hit of warming chai spices is unique enough to surprise and delight your guests. And so is the espresso glaze on top.

Get the recipe: Chai Cinnamon Rolls

10
/
12

Recipes Capricorn (December 22 to January 20): Contest-Winning Chocolate Potato Cake

Both practical and high-achieving, Capricorn will want to impress guests. In fact, “practical” and “high-achieving” is also how I wold describe this chocolate potato cake. It makes use of leftover mashed potatoes and doesn’t sacrifice on intensity of flavor. And since it’s a contest-winning recipe, you don’t have to worry about lowering your high standards while entertaining.

Get the recipe: Contest-Winning Chocolate Potato Cake

11
/
12

Recipes Aquarius (January 21 to February 19): Cranberry Curd Bars

There is always a hint of a rebellious streak in you, Aquarius. Cranberry can be a bit of a divisive ingredient, and thanks to its tangy sweetness, it’s usually added as a garnish. But since you’re always willing to dive in head-first, these cranberry curd bars are practically screaming your name. The tart cranberry is on full, glorious display here, and its boldness is sure to impress.

Get the recipe: Cranberry Curd Bars

12
/
12

Recipes Pisces (February 20 to March 20): Pumpkin Cheesecake Empanadas

Pisces, you walk a line between creativity and comfort every time you tie on your apron. Your curiosity and endless quest for new ideas can be exhausting, but it’s always rewarding in the end—just like these cheesecake empanadas. The hand pie gets a sweet, seasonal makeover from the addition of pumpkin. These will be the perfect way to satisfy both your inner Top Chef nerd and your guests.

Get the recipe: Pumpkin Cheesecake Empanadas