Yankees vs. Guardians prediction, odds, line, time: 2024 ALCS Game 3 picks, MLB playoff bets by proven model

The Cleveland Guardians will look to get back into the series when they take on the New York Yankees in a pivotal American League Championship Series Game 3 matchup on Thursday. New York took a commanding 2-0 series lead with a 6-3 win on Tuesday. The Yankees (94-68), winners of the AL East and the league’s top seed, are seeking to reach the World Series for the first time since 2009. The second-seeded Guardians (92-69), champions of the AL Central, are looking to make their first World Series appearance since 2016.

First pitch from Progressive Field in Cleveland is set for 5:08 p.m. ET. New York is a slight -111 favorite on the money line (risk $111 to win $100) in the latest Yankees vs. Guardians odds from SportsLine consensus, while the total number of runs Vegas thinks will be scored, or the over/under, is 7. Before making any Guardians vs. Yankees picks, be sure to see the MLB predictions and betting advice from SportsLine’s proven computer model.

The SportsLine Projection Model simulates every MLB game 10,000 times. It entered the 2024 NLCS and ALCS on a 32-17 roll on top-rated run-line picks (+822) that dates back to last season. Anybody following has seen strong returns.

Now, the model has set its sights on Yankees vs. Guardians and just locked in its picks and MLB predictions. You can head to SportsLine now to see the model’s picks. Here are several MLB odds and betting lines for Yankees vs. Guardians: 

  • Yankees vs. Guardians money line: New York -111, Cleveland -109
  • Yankees vs. Guardians over/under: 7 runs
  • Yankees vs. Guardians run line: New York -1.5 (+155)
  • NYY: The Yankees have covered the run line in 50 of their last 83 road games (+19.10 units)  
  • CLE: The Guardians have hit the game total under in 46 of their last 75 games (+19.40 units)  
  • Yankees vs. Guardians picks: See picks at SportsLine
  • Yankees vs. Guardians streaming: FuboTV (Try for free)

Why you should back the Yankees

New York is expected to send right-hander Clarke Schmidt (5-5, 2.85 ERA) to the mound. In 85.1 innings during the regular season, Schmidt allowed 71 hits, 27 earned runs and 30 walks, while striking out 93. He received a no-decision in the 3-2 ALDS Game 3 win over the Kansas City Royals on Oct. 9. In that game, he pitched 4.2 innings, allowing four hits, two earned runs and one walk, while striking out four. 

Second baseman Gleyber Torres is coming off a productive Game 2 performance, going 3-for-5 with two runs scored. He is batting .292 in the postseason and .444 in the series. In the decisive 3-1 ALDS Game 4 win at Kansas City last week, he was 2-for-5 with a double and one RBI. In 154 games during the regular season, Torres hit .257 with 26 doubles, 15 homers, 63 RBI and 80 runs scored. See which team to pick here.

Why you should back the Guardians

Cleveland’s pitching is the fifth-best in MLB during the postseason with a 3.30 ERA with 29 walks and 74 strikeouts and a 1.33 WHIP. In 60 innings, the Guardians have allowed 51 hits, 22 earned runs and five homers. Cleveland is 2-1 at home with a 2.00 ERA with 12 walks and 39 strikeouts and a 1.19 WHIP.

Helping power the Guardians offense is first baseman Josh Naylor. He was 2-for-4 with an RBI in the Game 2 loss to the Yankees. He has had some past success against New York. In 22 games, he has four doubles, three homers and 14 RBI. In 152 regular-season games in 2024, Naylor batted .243 with 27 doubles, 31 homers and 108 RBI. See which team to pick here.

How to make Guardians vs. Yankees picks

CBS Sports Staff
Read More

Latest

FCS Draft Surge: The Rise of Small-School Prospects in Modern NFL Conversations

FCS Draft Surge: The Rise of Small-School Prospects in Modern NFL Conversations Every spring, draft chatter once focused almost entirely on blue-blood programs such as Alabama or Ohio State. Today that narrative feels outdated. Championship rosters increasingly feature players who sharpened skills on modest Football Championship Subdivision (FCS) fields, developing technique rather than basking in

Two Trap Games that Georgia Tech Football Cannot Overlook This Season

While Georgia Tech Football did not face its usual gauntlet of a schedule last season, the Yellow Jackets are no strangers to playing tough schedules, usually among the toughest in the country. Georgia Tech is going to be playing 11 power conference opponents this season, with eight ACC opponents and a non-conference schedule that includes

“I cannot divorce the two”: How Star Wars is blending technology, creativity, and products into the experience itself

(Image credit: Disney) “It’s like a community, right? And it’s a global community that people really love and identify with.” That’s how Bobby Kim, Global Creative Director at Disney Consumer Products, describes Star Wars fandom. And it’s a framing that feels especially fitting as another May the 4th is behind us and we’re weeks out

Trump administration defends right to ban content moderation experts from US

The Trump administration is fighting for the right to keep some social media moderation advocates out of the US. On Wednesday, US District Court Judge James Boasberg heard arguments in a lawsuit between the nonprofit Coalition for Independent Technology Research (CITR) and Secretary of State Marco Rubio and other Trump administration officials. The suit concerns

Newsletter

Don't miss

FCS Draft Surge: The Rise of Small-School Prospects in Modern NFL Conversations

FCS Draft Surge: The Rise of Small-School Prospects in Modern NFL Conversations Every spring, draft chatter once focused almost entirely on blue-blood programs such as Alabama or Ohio State. Today that narrative feels outdated. Championship rosters increasingly feature players who sharpened skills on modest Football Championship Subdivision (FCS) fields, developing technique rather than basking in

Two Trap Games that Georgia Tech Football Cannot Overlook This Season

While Georgia Tech Football did not face its usual gauntlet of a schedule last season, the Yellow Jackets are no strangers to playing tough schedules, usually among the toughest in the country. Georgia Tech is going to be playing 11 power conference opponents this season, with eight ACC opponents and a non-conference schedule that includes

“I cannot divorce the two”: How Star Wars is blending technology, creativity, and products into the experience itself

(Image credit: Disney) “It’s like a community, right? And it’s a global community that people really love and identify with.” That’s how Bobby Kim, Global Creative Director at Disney Consumer Products, describes Star Wars fandom. And it’s a framing that feels especially fitting as another May the 4th is behind us and we’re weeks out

Trump administration defends right to ban content moderation experts from US

The Trump administration is fighting for the right to keep some social media moderation advocates out of the US. On Wednesday, US District Court Judge James Boasberg heard arguments in a lawsuit between the nonprofit Coalition for Independent Technology Research (CITR) and Secretary of State Marco Rubio and other Trump administration officials. The suit concerns

Apple’s 2028 iPhone display sounds impossible, but Samsung and LG are scrambling to build it

Android phones have had curved displays for years and accepted the distortion as the price of aesthetics. Apple is spending two years and billions of supplier dollars to not accept it. Apple's all-screen iPhone 20 mockup Ice Universe / X Apple doesn’t ask its suppliers to build things. It tells them to, hands them a

WD sees sustainability as key business driver in an ‘AI economy’

Hard drive company WD promoted long-term operations and sustainability executive Jackie Jung to become its first chief sustainability officer in February, as it steps up sales to companies building AI data centers. Her vision: Turn sustainability into a “brand” for WD, a strategy that reduces risk for the $6 billion company (formerly known as Western

5 Business Ideas Worth Starting in 2026

If there is one thing Nigerians understand well, it is how to spot opportunity inside hardship. In 2026, that mindset will matter more than ever. The economy is tough, competition is rising, and many people are looking for smarter ways to earn, build, and survive. But even in a difficult environment, some businesses still stand

Getting a business loan now comes with a frequent flyer upside

Australian fintech Prospa has partnered with Qantas Business Rewards, letting eligible SMEs earn up to 500,000 points per loan. What’s happening: Australian fintech lender Prospa has partnered with Qantas Business Rewards to allow eligible small and medium business owners to earn up to 500,000 Qantas Points per loan when taking out a Prospa Small Business