Compared to the combinations of Intel CPU and Nvidia graphics, gaming laptops with a CPU and a GPU both from AMD are in the minority. If all pure AMD machines have major driver problems similar to the current Alienware m17 R5, then this is unlikely to change. It’s a shame really, because the potential remains untapped.
Christian Hintze (translated by Jacob Fisher), Published ????????
We were quite excited about the all-AMD model from Alienware, which Dell sent us for a review. After all, we usually review gaming laptops with the usual Intel Core i7-12700H, sometimes also a model with i9-12900H and almost always in combination with an Nvidia RTX graphics card.
As a reviewer, it can be an exciting occasion when something different comes along instead of the usual one-size-fits-all. A gamer with an AMD Ryzen 9 6900HX and an AMD Radeon RX 6850M XT, for example. The latter falls roughly between the RTX 3070 and RTX 3080 in the performance class, but our gaming benchmarks reveal that it can even surpass an RTX 3080 Ti in selected games.
“Can” is the key word here, because the AMD combo is far too rarely able to unfold its full potential. In various games, the AMD team performs significantly below average. Sometimes the SmartAccess graphics switching in the m17 R5 doesn’t work properly and the game is handled by the integrated graphics only. Immature drivers seem to be another problem.
All in all, it is a pity that such a potentially strong system is drastically slowed down by the many inconsistencies. AMD, along with Dell and Alienware, still has some optimization work and quality control to do. Because I, as a reviewer and editor, would at least like to see more variety in gaming hardware in the future, which also works.
A C64 marked my entry into the world of PCs. I spent my student internship in the repair department of a computer shop and at the end of the day I was allowed to assemble my own 486 PC from “workshop remnants”. As a result of this, I later studied computer science at the Humboldt University in Berlin, with psychology also being added to my studies. After my first job as a research assistant at the university, I went to London for a year and worked for Sega in computer game translation quality assurance. This included working on games such as Sonic & All-Stars Racing Transformed and Company of Heroes. I have been writing for Notebookcheck since 2017.
Translator: Jacob Fisher – Translator – 148 articles published on Notebookcheck since 2022
Growing up in regional Australia, I first became acquainted with computers in my early teens after a broken leg from a football (soccer) match temporarily condemned me to a predominately indoor lifestyle. Soon afterwards I was building my own systems. Now I live in Germany, having moved here in 2014, where I study philosophy and anthropology. I am particularly fascinated by how computer technology has fundamentally and dramatically reshaped human culture, and how it continues to do so.
Christian Hintze, 2023-01-18 (Update: 2023-01-17)
Read More
Clora Serna