NFL preseason: Parsing through overreactions to Week 1's storylines, starting with Shedeur Sanders

Football

The first week of the NFL preseason is in the books, leading to a slew of rational, not-wild-at-all opinions as people get their first taste of football for the 2025 season. There are a lot of things causing people to overreact. And we all already know where an overreactions piece on the NFL has to start.

Let the process play out with Shedeur Sanders

Shedeur Sanders had a good start to his rookie year with a solid showing against the Panthers in his first preseason game. Sanders played the bulk of the snaps in the game, throwing two touchdowns and making some other nice throws. It wasn’t a perfect outing and he needs to continue to adjust to the NFL’s speed, but he showed he deserves a chance to compete for a roster spot as the Browns make some tough decisions as to how many quarterbacks they carry on the roster this season.

Advertisement

[Join or create a Yahoo Fantasy Football league for the 2025 NFL season]

That’s all it really has to be. However, now there are people saying (of course) Sanders should be getting to practice with the first-team offense. All of sudden, two-time Coach of the Year Kevin Stefanski is some clueless bum who doesn’t know how to run his team. In the name of a fifth-round quarterback. Now, Sanders very well might not be the worst QB on the team — third-round pick Dillon Gabriel has yet to make his preseason debut — but he still has a ways to go before he cements his roster spot.

Just take the positives as they come and remember, the preseason is a different ballgame. A couple of years ago, current Browns quarterback Kenny Pickett lit up the preseason, causing people to buy in on his prospect as a potential star quarterback. Now, he’s in the same battle for his career as Sanders. Be easy, remember the preseason is the preseason. Let the process play out.

Anthony Richardson isn’t doomed just yet

Hey, not a great start for a guy trying to salvage his career as a starting quarterback and former first-round draft pick. Anthony Richardson’s attempt to continue being the starter for the Indianapolis Colts got off to a horrible start when he was knocked out of the preseason opener after taking a big hit from Ravens pass rusher David Ojabo on a protection bust between himself and the offensive line. There have been a bunch of reactions surrounding the hit, namely that this is another piece of data that suggests Richardson is not ready for the opportunity placed in front of him. Daniel Jones will start the next preseason game, but that was planned even before Richardson was hurt.

While this definitely harms Richardson’s chances to be the opening day starter, it doesn’t mean the book is necessarily closed. The best chance for head coach Shane Steichen and others to keep their jobs is still Richardson becoming the QB they hoped they were getting in 2023. He is still fairly far away from that goal, but it doesn’t mean all hope is lost. There’s still time to learn, and his competition for the job isn’t exactly fierce, with Jones being his primary opposition.

Advertisement

Again, just take these things day by day in the preseason. There’s not much correlation here in regard to regular-season success.

Jets look to be buying in

Perhaps this is a reminder to myself to not overreact to stuff, but it looks like head coach Aaron Glenn is really starting to figure things out with the Jets already. For a team that looked so unbelievably lifeless toward the end of last season, it was incredible to see the fire and physicality they played with in their preseason opener. The Jets had a strong performance from their offensive line, had some great performances from a couple running backs and Justin Fields made a couple big plays to inspire confidence.

On the other side of the field, the Jets’ first-team defense flew around the ball, with Sauce Gardner making some of the best plays he has in a year. Their first preseason game was a reminder that the Jets, for all their faults last season, are not a team lacking talent. They look like they’ll be a tough out this year, but, like I’ve said in the first couple sections, it’s just the first week of the preseason.

Advertisement

Cam Ward looks like the real deal

The last one will be another reminder to myself that the preseason is just the preseason, but the oft-forgotten first overall draft pick, Cam Ward of the Tennessee Titans, will be making his NFL debut this year and looks like he can take this offense to a more credible level than where it was last season. Ward looked comfortable operating the offense and let it rip a couple times into tight coverage. He showed off his trademark playmaking ability out of the pocket and was generally more competent than anything the Titans have had under center in a long time.

Now, there’s still a ways to go until Ward can be considered a bona fide franchise quarterback, but his Titans debut certainly showed the framework is there.

Read More Charles McDonald

Latest

NFL Analyst Raises Red Flags Over Arvell Reese’s Fit As Edge Rusher on PFSN’s Football Debate Club

As the 2026 NFL Draft approaches, few defensive prospects have generated as much intrigue as Ohio State’s Arvell Reese. Widely viewed as one of the most talented defenders in the class, Reese’s versatility has made him a standout on scouting boards. However, with that versatility comes an ongoing debate about how he projects at the

Athena launches FabOrchestrator, an agentic AI platform for manufacturing execution systems

In short: Athena Technology Solutions, a Fremont-based MES integrator with roughly 120 employees, has launched FabOrchestrator, an agentic AI platform for manufacturing that automates reporting, support tickets, system modelling, and code generation for semiconductor and electronics factories. Built in partnership with Bangalore-based LLM at Scale.AI, it layers LLM capabilities on top of the Siemens Opcenter

Concord’s in the Rap Game: Latest Tie-Up Sees Company Managing Pop Smoke, Ski Mask the Slump God Catalogs

Photo Credit: Concord + Victor Victor Worldwide Concord announces a multi-year partnership with Victor Victor Worldwide to expand Concord’s presence in hip-hop. Independent music company Concord has announced a strategic multi-year venture with Victor Victor Worldwide (VVW), a New York-based record label founded by global entertainment executive Steven Victor. The partnership will help drive VVW’s

Want Your Music Featured on Netflix? Having a Major Label Helps

Music More Netflix blow-ups, please (Photo Credit: Yousafbhutta)Music Bagging...

Newsletter

Don't miss

NFL Analyst Raises Red Flags Over Arvell Reese’s Fit As Edge Rusher on PFSN’s Football Debate Club

As the 2026 NFL Draft approaches, few defensive prospects have generated as much intrigue as Ohio State’s Arvell Reese. Widely viewed as one of the most talented defenders in the class, Reese’s versatility has made him a standout on scouting boards. However, with that versatility comes an ongoing debate about how he projects at the

Athena launches FabOrchestrator, an agentic AI platform for manufacturing execution systems

In short: Athena Technology Solutions, a Fremont-based MES integrator with roughly 120 employees, has launched FabOrchestrator, an agentic AI platform for manufacturing that automates reporting, support tickets, system modelling, and code generation for semiconductor and electronics factories. Built in partnership with Bangalore-based LLM at Scale.AI, it layers LLM capabilities on top of the Siemens Opcenter

Concord’s in the Rap Game: Latest Tie-Up Sees Company Managing Pop Smoke, Ski Mask the Slump God Catalogs

Photo Credit: Concord + Victor Victor Worldwide Concord announces a multi-year partnership with Victor Victor Worldwide to expand Concord’s presence in hip-hop. Independent music company Concord has announced a strategic multi-year venture with Victor Victor Worldwide (VVW), a New York-based record label founded by global entertainment executive Steven Victor. The partnership will help drive VVW’s

Want Your Music Featured on Netflix? Having a Major Label Helps

Music More Netflix blow-ups, please (Photo Credit: Yousafbhutta)Music Bagging...

SoE necessary but not sufficient, business leaders say

PE­TER CHRISTO­PHER Se­nior Mul­ti­me­dia Re­porter pe­ter.christo­pher@guardian.co.tt Heavy hand­ed but nec­es­sary giv­en the state of crime in T&T. This was a com­mon as­sess­ment from var­i­ous busi­ness groups when asked for their per­spec­tive on the lat­est de­c­la­ra­tion of a state of emer­gency in the coun­try. The T&T Cham­ber of In­dus­try and Com­merce, in a re­leased is­sued yes­ter­day

The Big Business of Carolyn Bessette-Kennedy

Can a nine-episode limited series really impact an entire season of shopping trends? Today brands are experiencing—and chasing—the “Carolyn Bessette-Kennedy effect” as a result of Ryan Murphy’s Love Story. And in many cases, it’s more pervasive than they could have prepared for. The FX series, based on the relationship between John F. Kennedy Jr. and

‘Mind Your Own Business’: Kamal Haasan Rebukes Trump Over ‘Permission’ To Buy Russian Oil

Updated 8 March 2026 at 18:20 IST Actor and Rajya Sabha MP Kamal Haasan has hit out at US President Donald Trump after America announced that it has given India temporary "permission" to buy Russian oil amid global supply disruptions caused by the Middle East conflict. 'Mind Your Own Business': Kamal Haasan Rebukes Trump Over