Sometimes they get it right, sometimes they wouldn’t get it right.
Long Islanders insist that the fictional town in New England where Steven Spielberg’s classic film “Jaws” is set is actually inspired by a local legend from their own community.
“Monster” hunter fisherman Frank Mundus — a proud son of Montauk — was the inspiration for Robert Shaw’s salty Capt. Quint in the movie, which turns 50 on Friday, family and friends said.
“Anybody who knows anything about fishing knows that it’s based on him,” the shark hunter’s daughter Pat Mundus told The Post.
“Everybody on the East End knows,” she added of the mighty man who died in 2008 at 82.
Mundus, who lives in Greenport, said people still ask her daily if she’s related to Frank.
The Brooklyn-born seaman came to the Montauk Point from the north jersey shore in the early 1950s to do what wasn’t traditionally done before: intentionally go out in search of the feared apex predators of the sea.
The self-branded “monster fisherman” turned the tide of “the family-friendly inshore fishing image that Montauk had,” said Pat, a former oil tanker worker who is now 68.
Mundus couldn’t give two flying fins, however.
“He branded himself a ‘monster fisher’ because he knew that it would attract more charter customers,” she explained, adding that there was a method to the madness.
As a boy in the city, Mundus tried jumping from roof to roof between a pair of three-story buildings and fell to the ground, breaking his arm and developing a near-fatal infection. The miracle recovery — one that hindered his schooling to the point he finished eighth grade at nearly 18 — is what gave Mundus his “big booming energy.”
“He painted one toenail red and the other blue and called them port and starboard. He wore an earring. He went barefoot everywhere. He played pranks and made a public spectacle of himself.”
Perhaps Mundus’ most iconic gag was when “he had another guy dress up as a Frankenstein-like monster and they put him in a waterproof casket and marked it offshore.”
“They ‘discovered’ the guy, they brought the casket back and opened it up on the dock, and this big monster sprang out.”
By the 1960s, the attention-grabbing antics were enough to reel in “Jaws” author-to-be Peter Benchley.
The penman fatefully rode on Mundus’ boat, the Cricket, which was named for the running joke that its captain looked like Jiminy.
“My father was a very intelligent person, but not terribly well-educated, so he didn’t know who Peter Benchley was,” Mundus, one of Frank’s three daughters, said.
“He just thought it was a guy who was interested in listening to stories about catching fish.”
The depiction of Quint and the lack of recognition of the real story sent Mundus overboard, his daughter said.
“He had very carefully crafted his whole image in his own brand for 30 years,” she added. “And then some guy just came along and stole it without acknowledging who he was.”
Even Suffolk County Executive Ed Romaine laments to this day that Mundus and the setting of Montauk were shortchanged.
“Frank Mundus was a legendary fisherman who could be in Hemingway’s ‘Old Man and the Sea,’” he told The Post.
What ‘Jaws’ got wrong
Mundus said her father isn’t the bitter old salt that his Hollywood counterpart.
“He was never in the Navy, he had no revenge against evil — he didn’t seek restitution for the loss of his shipmates, who were all eaten by sharks, none of that,” she said.
“He had a flair for being outrageous, but he wasn’t angry and pissed off, and would never take a baseball bat to a VHF radio.”
When they saw the film in theaters together, Mundus wasn’t afraid to speak his mind.
“A couple of times he stood up and said, ‘that’s impossible, that wouldn’t ever work!’” she recalled.
“He laughed through all the parts that everybody else was totally scared about.”
Although Pat said that her dad moved on from his gripes, Roy Scheider apparently didn’t get the message and worried Mundus would do something like give him a black eye — like a doll’s eye.
The man who played Chief Brody told publicist Todd Shapiro he was petrified of doing film anniversary events on the East End in case he would run into Mundus, according to the PR consultant who tried recruiting Scheider for a reunion.
Every morning, the NY POSTcast offers a deep dive into the headlines with the Post’s signature mix of politics, business, pop culture, true crime and everything in between. Subscribe here!
The real sequel
Regardless of whether it was fact or fiction, the fame of “Jaws” reshaped Montauk in the 1980s and transformed the then-quaint fishing village into Sharktown USA.
Sam Hershowitz began hosting annual shark tournaments at his marina on Star Island, “that brought people all the way up from the Carolinas,” he said.
“The first year we had 82 boats, the year after we had 150,” Hershowitz, 85, told The Post, adding that he would play John Williams’ iconic “Jaws” score before they all left for sea.
“The motel owners used to thank me because they would be booked solid.”
During the 1986 competition, Mundus and his former colleague Donnie Braddick made more fishing history.
They brought in what some record books call the largest ever rod-and-reel caught great white at a whopping 17 feet and 3,427 pounds.
Sam’s Star Island Yacht Club and Marina has a replica of the big guy that remains a tourist selfie favorite to this day, Hershowitz said, adding that due to shark fishing regulations, it’s a record that will never be broken.
Braddick, now 69, was captaining a tuna fishing boat when he spotted tons of sharks devouring a dead whale about 25 miles southeast of Montauk Point.
The boaters he was with were too frightened, so Braddick had to wait until he brought them back to make a go at the sharks.
En route back to land, Braddick spotted Mundus coming in from an overnight charter.
“If you needed heart surgery and the best heart surgeon was passing by, it would be a good idea to grab him,” Braddick, who left Montauk for North Carolina when it became “credit cards and spending mommy and daddy’s money,” told The Post.
The duo returned to port and stocked up on essentials — beer and pizza — and headed back out in their respective boats into the moonlit hours.
“In the middle of the night, we felt the boat get bumped…and then it was like, ‘oh boy, they’re here,’” he recalled of the “all-star” team that sprang into action to nab a great white.
“We reeled the boat to the fish, not the fish to the boat…after an hour and a half, that fish was like ‘f–k it, I’ve had enough of this s–t’ and it just charged the boat…All I see is him steaming at us.”
Finally, after masterful gaffing and angling, the beast fell to the men of the sea and was towed back to land.
“The rest was one big friggin’ party,” added Braddick. “A lot of people know about it, and they still talk about it.”
While the legend of Mundus is as eternal as the sea, Pat is ready for a new wave and wants to live a life of her own rather than echo family tales, she said.
Still, there’s one thing Mundus told his kin that she remembers to this day.
“Fear is just not understanding something,” Pat recalled.
“And if you want to get over a fear, you have to gain competency in it.”