Announcing the Winners of Our 2024 Cookie Exchange

We’re delighted to announce the winners of the 2024 Cookie Exchange, hosted by Taste of Home and Kelsey Elizabeth! Back in October, Ohio bakery owner Kelsey Shepard invited her Instagram followers to join us in Cleveland on December 5. The 300 tickets sold out in three minutes!

On the night of the Cookie Exchange, talented bakers from across the Midwest—and even one from Washington State—braved snowy roads to attend the party with their six dozen carefully crafted cookies in tow. Everyone nibbled their way through countless snickerdoodles, spritz, gingerbread, rugelach and more, then filled a box with their favorites to take home.

While guests mingled and munched, judges (aka the hosts) scouted out the tastiest, most beautiful cookies in the bunch. It was clear that every cookie and bar was made with love, making it a difficult job. These are the treats they couldn’t stop thinking about, in no particular order.

Recipes The Top Cookies

Taste of Home

Mini Cranberry Pavlovas

Baked by Devin Trout from Lorain, Ohio

These mini meringue nests were crispy on the outside and gooey on the inside, just like a pavlova should be. The judges were smitten with the adorable little jars of homemade cranberry-orange sauce included in Devin’s interactive display.

Decorated Sugar Cookie Cutouts

Baked by Melissa Falk from Avon, Ohio

Melissa describes herself as a decorator first, but her buttery sugar cookies tasted as divine as they looked. She flooded her cutout Christmas trees with royal icing, and scattered edible beads and more icing over the top for a polished design.

An Ode to Lekko Shortbread Cookies

Baked by Alex Welch from Euclid, Ohio

For this year’s cookie exchange, Alex was inspired by a latte at Lekko, her favorite local coffee shop (and “happy place”). She infused a classic shortbread recipe with maple and rosemary flavors, then piped a big ribbon of espresso buttercream on each cookie.

Taste of Home

Texas Sheet Cake Cookies

Baked by Tracy Pesho from North Royalton, Ohio

Tracy started off on the Cookie Exchange waitlist, and we’re so glad a spot opened up for her! Her dark chocolate cookies were based on a family recipe for Texas sheet cake. Just like their full-size namesake, Tracy’s moist and chewy cookies were slathered with crackly chocolate icing.

Hungarian Nut Roll Cookies

Baked by Lance Jendrusik from Lorain, Ohio

While most cookies at the exchange were round, Lance’s initially stood out to judges because they were cigar-shaped. The tender, flaky cookies were filled with walnuts, making a wonderful combination of textures.

Iced Brown Butter Oatmeal Cookies

Baked by Elizabeth Tittle from Cleveland, Ohio

Elizabeth elevated a classic oatmeal cookie recipe by browning the butter. The result: a rich, nutty flavor. Her iced cookies were some of the biggest at the exchange, but judges ate every crumb.

A giant congratulations to all the winners!

Cookie Exchange 101